Anwarul Islam Mukul from North
- Well done and congratulations to all winners
|71.70.137.xxx
|Aug-25-2008
Well done and congratulations to all winners I felt so sorry for those artist who didn't win.Well done, everyone!
I think they're being exposed with their new determination. Thanks to all judges thank for for pointing out who gained highest score
Its very hard for me to write a review on this artist.
It is a very tough competition for there are three styles of music competing. From my point of view that pahari song was very nice
Lyrics and composition is remarkable. a beautiful pahari song I feel deeply concerned about these artists who despite being so talented , Thank you.
how it's happened..? Shadhona ki kore out hoye gelo..? dhuuurrrrrrrr....shalar stupid people of Bangladesh...eder haate judgement ta tule deyai hoise mosto boro ek vul...
i m vry sad 2 see shadhona out...but i think its b'cuz of her own fault of sinigng the same type of song over nd over.she shud've sung something else dis time instead od pahari.anyway congrats to lizaaaa...vry happy to see tasmi to go next round..
I wanted Rana to make it to the next round instead of Bappi!!
My expectation was Tasmi, Liza, and Rana. I thought may be at the end of the track round Shefali is going to be picked up by the closeup1 authority just like it happened last time
Bappi got 44 which is the second best out of all the contestant after 46 by judges. you cant leave Bappi out. nd ofcourse i liked Rana too...Rana should hav been in instead of Robin.
feel very sorry for rana.
i cant believe tasmi got suc low number votes...infact i was over confident about public vote for tasmi.my intuition was that tasmi,robin will be surely in,next one would be either rana or bappi.
now that tasmi ke ana holo,thnx judges.
ranar jonno khub kharap lagse.
evabe short-cut kore contestant der out kore deya sotti not fair.they shud extend to select 5 from every round instead of 3.
rana dont worry,u will be back with a bang next year.we concentrated more on robin this time... :zzz
I agree with #7 and #13,its totally the public sympathy he got,the result should be based on talent not based on sympathy.We saw it happening last two years when Nolok and Salma got the public sympathy,but ppl is emotional and any decission taken emotionally is not always the right one.Thank God Tasmi got in...she is the most deserving one but its a pity that she will get out in the next round again and I can declare now that Robin is going to be next Close up 1 undoubtedly bcuz of public backup.
robin will not be no.1 but he will be among top 10.thats gud enuf.
after chosing top 10,real contest will start n public will vote wisely,not emotionally i believe.
hey lament,plz upload the result-sheet of this round,n the whole 16s result now.thx :zzz
I never want to see Robin in top 10...he is not perfect enough to go in top 10...Public should see the talent on this stage, not any other thing else...Congratulations Tasmi to come back again...but i'm really really feeling sorry for Shadhona, Jemy, Rana.......
thanks tashmi is back. we should remember that its a competition. we should judge them according to their merit not to be biased. its not a place to show sympathy. we did the same mistake in 2006 (nolok) nad 2007 (salma). its totally unfair. sorry rana. u deserve better than what u got.
Sorry for Rana...But judges have done good job by returning Tasmi in the the next round. Thanks judges, specially Bulbul..Bcs he requested to get back Tasmi...He also have done another job for Robin by requesting people to vote Robin after his singing in the last time. I think his comment have worked significantly to make people emotional.
Close up authority should take 3/4 contested to make the programme more popular...and get quality singer. We, the peoples in BD, are emotional..so sometimes authority should take special consideration to take 3/4 contested like Rana,Jemi, Arman, Shefali..
Don't you guys think that bringing Tasmi in has raptured the impartial character of this program?
Rana obtained 4th place in this round and Tasmi obtained 5th place. If they have to take only one, why not Rana?
Judges have never given scores correctly. One of them even cried for Polbasha, whom people rejected strongly. How will I be convinced that judges were correct when they gave such a high score to Tasmi. From the SMS, it is clear that people didn't like Tasmi (it is irrelevant here whether people understand songs or not, if Close-up 1 authority and judges think that people do not understand songs, then they should not have included the option for SMS, once they have done it they should have obeyed the rule).
According to the rule of this competiotion, those contestants who will be the top three (scores from judges and SMS combinedly), they will go to the next round.
awesome. tasmi jabar joggo silo. onek valo lagse. ekta justice holo ontoto. robin er bodole rana gale aro valo lagto. robin er golai special kisu paina. robin nischoi shefali, or debasish er chaite valo gaina.
vai 27, i like to see robin, but the singer who has got the highest scores of the whole 5 tracks how you can deny her (Tasmi), so i think the judges at least did the right thing at last, they tried to save jamy too, but emotional people voted only lalon's song in that episode. by the way nobody will care whether or not you have stopped watching the so called "impartial" close up 1 by you.
sorry, i did not write this personally to undermine you.
thanks.
I think robin will be lethal in the next rounds because ogf public sympathy, unfortunately not for skill. sorry for sadhona but good to see tasmi is in
I wanna congrat tasmi...n the 3 judges as well as they took step to take her next round..as a audience,as a part of million music-freaks I am so pleased to judges verdict..she deserve to go next round..cheers TASMI..we need the sweet voice of LIZA..TASMI..N melodious BAPPI...N finally also congrat ROBIN... We hv lost so many sweet voices..SHEFALY,SHUKLA,JEMI,SHADONA,DEBU...I really feel sorry for them as they couldnt go next but I think they also deserve to go..anyway looking forward more brilliant efforts fm TASMI,LIZA,PARUL N DINA..THANKS ALL
:cry
i was waiting for today that the judges will call back to shefali for next round. but that is in vain. they did not call her.
still there is time to call her back for next round.
thanks
Total systems are not perfect as the singers like Debu, Jemy, Rana, Arman and Shefaly are omitted. Percentage of the total marks should be of Judges:60 and SMS:40. Finally no comments should be done in such a way that grow public simpathy for any singer like Robin.
We gave call ntv authority so many time. requesting to pick up more than 3. We are happy that they have done it.
4 jon neya tei amader onek prio, rana bad hoye gelo. Feel sorry for rana. jodi 3 jon nito, then kake je haratam. God knows.
Ekhon je 4 jon ache, tader ekjon o jodi bad porto , ki je obostha hoto chintai korte parchi na.
But ekta jinish ekebarei buzlam na,
Jei tasmi er gan eto valo laglo overall, and jei tasmi er eto praise sunlam charidik, sei tasmi keno eto kom vote pelo ????
ITs a question............
again thanks ntv, to keep the request of your probash-dorsok...
Inshalla in future for good things we wil keep our voice like this......
bull shit.
why only 1 will be able to go through next round..?
if tashmi can go through ..shefaly , debu, rana..and many other qualified singer who participated but drop out for small sms or fall in a hardcore group or participate from low network area..are also deserve to go to next round.
i think this was the last episode of track round ..so judges were sympathetised to Tashmi.
Yes ,no doubt tasmi sings well ..she deserves to go to next round ...but other competetor who also did well should have considered.
they could have another round with the fallens to give them all another fight back chance.
No. 29, under which rule they picked Tasmi when she placed 5th? Judges could give her 50 out of 50, that's not a question, but according to the rule of the competition, only three top contestants from a track round (combinedly from judges score and SMS) will go to the next round, regardless whether any contestant gets highest or lowest from judges / sms. Therefore, the organizers of the program as well as the judges were completely favored Tasmi who failed to become one of the Top three according to the rule of competion.
You are correct, it is completely irrelevant whether I watch this program or not.
I am happy and greatful to all voters, who voted heavily to Robin. He is a disable person. it doesn't mean that he can't sing. After winning first 2 rounds, Robin arrived in this stage. I would say he didn't perform so bad at all. Its a great judgement from all over.
I am also happy for Tasmi. But the way she was picked thats I totally disagree. Instead picking Tasmi as 16th contestent, If the honourable judges would have picked Tasmi, Rana, Arman, Shefaly, and Jamy and would have made a group of 20, I guess It would have been more nice and fair. Like Tasmi, Shefaly, Arman, Rana, jamy all they sang well and got good marks. i don'e see a very big different between 16 and 20. If it would be a group of 20, then they could have divided it into 2 groups 10 each for the next rounds.
Finally, I would say that close up 1 is not a quite fair contest program.
It is clear that tasmi is the best singer in this closeup 1. So, as she get chance to go to next round defenitely its a good thing. So, how it happenned its no matter.
As far as we understand the rule of closeup1 is that those contestants who will be in top three in his / her group, will go to the next round. It was never mentioned in the program that a suprise 16th will be added based only on the judgement of judges.
I strongly condemn the organizers of Closeup1 as they picked a contestant who became 5th in her group.
It is irrelevant how beutiful Tasmi sings, but based on the rule of the competiotion, she MUST not go to the next round. This program is not a fair one, judges and organizers of the program failed to remain impartial. If Tasmi has been picked, then 4th and 5th of all the groups should also be picked. It is not a matter how much a contestant gets from judges because the final score is based on both the scores from judges and sms.
CloseUp1 has nakedly shown to the public that it is not a fair and impartial program. There must be something going on behind the screem.
#45, to me and to some of my friends, Tasmi has not sung well. We respect your thought, but according to us she is not a good singer. We preserve the same right for voting as you do and we did not vote for Tasmi, that's why she became 5th and should be kicked out of next round.
Tasmi is in through unusual means. For you it may not be a matter how Tasmi is in, but for us it is a BIG factor. Judges and organizers of closeup1 practiced unfair means to bring in Tasmi.
Closeup1 2008 
:eek :roll :upset :cry 
tasmi 
igh
"yeh PDA jini...
want u more pic ?...
liza liza liza li...
LIZA
liza