very upset for sms for Apu,he got highest mark but sms only 53,000. I thought Apu will be winner this year but shaju make classic perfomance. Apu also come from a poor family next time he will get more sms , need choice the song.
anyway congrats to shaju/happy leon/atiq /dina and my favourite APU atleast best of 10
Since I don't have any personal room my pc is usually in my dad's room and he took a day off..He was sleeping dead till 1 PM and I went to work at 12:30...I couldn't help..
Hey Mili....I am quite agree with you. Parul has been eliminated for Faty Fahmida. But trust me I became so upset for Apurbo. For me Apurbo is having a God gifted voice. But unfortunately, he got very poor votes. All most about to eliminate. Just saved. If Apurbo would have been elimnated today, it would have been a big disaster for this year contest. Because no doubdt that he is the best singer among all till now.
I was also upset, why Apurbo did not get more votes? I don't think it is Fahmida who did that to Parul. I think it is Bulbul, he always supports polli/lalon singers no one else!
How comes Shaju got more votes than Apurbo, and Atik? I hate the voters. Can anybody realize that Apurbo was almost out of the contest today? Bangladeshi voters are Funny, I guess.
I feel to laugh for them.
Shaju has a extra quality, he is the most entertaining singer. He is not receiving any sympathy votes like other closeup1 champions from previous years. People just love his singing style, it is realy nice.
Hi Shimu,If Bangladeshi voters are funy then who are you?Are you Bangladeshi?You feel laugh for Bangladeshi,please behave yourself.Sazu deserved to get that much vote so it doesn't mean that 140,000 voters are funy.As you said Bangladeshi voters are funy then who are voted by online are they funy too?
Again Shaju proved ppl like him so much. He is the most entertaining singer. Also, he is different than other closeup1 champions, he is not receiving any sympathy votes, ppl just love his performance and singing style. So best wishes for Shaju.
these 5 singer is all right..i voted all of them.
BUT shaju's vote is too high and apurbo's vote is too low!!!
now apu is at risky point.....which is bothering me.
Yes, you ar right. Shaju's vote is too high, and Apurbo's vote is too low. Don't worry this is quite normal in Close up 1 contest. If it wouldn't happened, then definitely we would had got Razib and Muhin as Banglades Idle from 2005 and 2006 contest.
I was a big supporter of Razib and Muhin instead of Nolok and Salma. But I believe Nolok is a real talent. I was angry because previous yrs people voted based on their social status. This year I am voting for Shaju because he is totaly different than other singers, he is not only a good singer also most entertaining. He deserves that many votes.
I don't think Shaju got this votes because of sympathy. So far he is not begging or making up any story to get the sympathy votes from public like other closeup1 champions. So to me his votes are genuine, this is why I respect him. I also like Apurbo, but I don't think he can be closeup1, may be in top 5.
It depends, to me and all other voters (1 lakh) he is better than shefaly. We have to wait, don't know yet he is like nolok/salma, or not. I hope he can sing other songs not only polli.
bhai arif usa,tomake ashonko donno bad amar moner kotha ta boleso.eto shundor gola eto mark 6 ar shala bodai public sms korche 53,000??? my god i know shaju/purno ora valo gai but compare apurbo i am dam sure he can sing better than shaju.look at his marks...tai bole sms eto kom.....disaster theke beche gieache apu. bhai apu tumi advance hoi, ei mamu dorkar hoile tumar shara musical education er expenxess bear korbe....ntv authority can contact me through e mail
I,m happy to see the result cause its quiet identical to my expectation n I was not sure among parul n dina who would go but here found that Dina is going with other four..congrats to all five..here I,v seen one thing n also agree with many commentators that Apu's vocal is melodious than others but got less public votes ..n one commentator named mamu fm tokyo wanna to patronise him for higher musical study, thanks him for his good approach to a singer like apu..I think he is a real artist in heart...once again thanks all 5 winners
I am very happy for results the closeup 1.Shazu,Apu,Leon i love all.Shazu you are a closeup 1 of the year.I whish you for voting.Apu you are best singer of closeup 1.I think you are a good perfomer.I wish you good luck.Leon i love your voice.I wish you for singing.Thinks all for voting Shazu,Leon and Apu.Sorry for Parul,Asha and shriti best of luck.OK
I think most limitation of close up 1 is..they focused on lalon or folk song. But there is something else.. And dear voter..did u notice..only APU didn't arrage any campain for voting..he is very poor family and not supported by rich doner..but i will vote for him ..definitely
hi very thanks to dip.i watched it again it is only apu who didn't arrange any campain first time i saw he came from a poor family. we must support him, i say thanks "mamu" who already offer apu to help for his higher education.if he trained by good "ostad" he can be a new subir nondi or??????
why his area man not supported this talent boy!!
ALL WE LOVE DINA
- "DINA THE KOKILA OF BANGLADESH"!!
|203.122.101.xxx
|Sep-01-2008
The best female singer DINA, who was performed as like as professional singer Sabina or Runa, even SHE got better number than LEON by the judges. But why she has got the poor sms by the general viewers?!
We were stunning to see the result of excellent Dina!
Actually we the public do not know the real DIAMOND, or it's real value! One day, we the public could understand 'Who is DINA', Insha-Allah! Dina is all rounder awesome singer "THE KOKILA OF BANGLADESH"!!
Thanks lament for uploading the episode. ami to vebesilam, ebar sunday te kisu dekhai ni. i know it takes lots of effort and time to upload every single episode. can't thank you enough. you rock, keep it up.
The result today was exactly what i expected, although not in the order i wanted it.
You guys can say that I am bad. But inside and out I am always same. See Ahmed Imtiaz Bulbul Bhai. He is always praising almost all of the Close UP1 singers. Is he giving everyone same marks/points? What the use of that praising?
I am not against his policy. He is a good man. But you see, when a singer gets less mark/point from us, what will (s)he thinks? You praised me a lot in front of us singers and TV public, but now you have given me poor marks/points. Is it right?
Don't you think they should know their mistake or everyone has the right to know their mistakes? As far as I know in UK, USA, CANADA, AUSTRALIA, every student asks their teachers when they get less mark to show their problem. If they get 3.5 out of 5, they ask where is my problem why I didn't get 5 out of 5.
Same thing applies in these country when a candidate is not hired in a job position, they have 100% right to ask the employer/interviewer, 'why I am not hired'. Where is their lackings or mistake for their failure? Our Close Up 1 singers and public should have that guts to take constructive criticism.
Truth is always bitter if it goes against you. I don't believe that our comments effect public in their voting. If it effects, then SHEFALI, PALBASHA, JEMY would not be out so early. We praised a lot for them. Even the great talent TASMI would be out after 1st SMS round.
We, the three stage judges, are enough educated in music. But the education level in music of PUBLIC JUDGES are not same. So everything (the results) gets upside down by the votes of public. I strongely feel that it is our (stage judges) duty to increase the level of better music understanding of public.
Dear Fahmida!
In the stage judge time, the most common comments from you was ' i am not getting what i am expecting'. Now my question, what u expect, r u clear urself? if u know then why not u pont out exactly their fault. If u comment like widely/unclearly then it is confusing for candidate and as well as the public about ur judgmenet.
Closeup1 2008 
"yeh PDA jini...
want u more pic ?...
liza liza liza li...
LIZA
liza